At the Israel Insurance Agents Association conference held in Eilat with the participation of over 600 attendees, a panel of insurance company CEOs convened, with the participation of Israel Insurance Agents Association President Moshik Ben Porat. Taking part in the panel were Harel CEO Nir Cohen, Migdal CEO Ronen Agassi, Menora Mivtachim Insurance CEO Michael Kalman, and Clal CEO Yoram Naveh. The panel was moderated by journalist Yehuda Sharoni. At the focus of the discussion were the issue of the compensation structure and agent commissions, alongside the question of the agent’s status, the decrease in management fees, the phenomenon of mobility, and trends in the capital market. The President of the Association, Moshik Ben Porat, referred to the words of the Commissioner of the Capital Market Authority who defined the agents as a “distribution channel,” and said that agents are business partners who accompany the policyholder for years in claims, status changes, and job transitions. Ben Porat called on the companies to reduce direct sales, including in motor and home insurance, and presented the Capital Market Authority data for 2025, according to which 43% of license holders earn less than 250 thousand Shekels gross per year (approximately 20 thousand Shekels per month including VAT). He promised that next year this rate will drop, and that agents’ incomes will rise already in the coming year. The issue of agent commissions and the compensation structure ignited the central debate in the panel. Ronen Agassi claimed that the root of the problem is not the height of the compensation but its distorted structure: paying the full commission at the initial time of sale instead of spreading it over the service provision period harms the client and the manufacturer and creates an incentive for excessive mobility. Yoram Naveh reinforced this position and agreed that the current incentive method pushes for over-mobility in pension savings, something that harms the long-term vision and non-tradable assets. In contrast to them, Nir Cohen claimed that the discussion on compensation is populist, since this is a completely free market with no law dictating commissions, in which companies are permitted to employ direct salespeople but choose to work with independent agents who are compensated on success only. Michael Kalman added that comparing commissions between different industries is superficial, and that compensation must reflect the value and contribution of each agent. Ben Porat proposed, on the other hand, to compensate agents for portfolio retention in order to curb unnecessary mobility. On the subject of management fees, Naveh noted that their decrease and the default funds reform benefited the public, and presented a combination of high returns and low management fees that place Israel at the global top. Alongside this, he criticized the fact that commissions in the banking system in pension advice remained higher than the management fees themselves, which prevented the development of advice in banks. Ben Porat closed the discussion with a promise that the Association will act to enhance the status of the agent and increase their income.

Share.
Leave A Reply

Exit mobile version